| Pos | Name | Skill | Performance | |
| K | Neville Southall | 15 | +3.00 (20.00%) | |
| D | Victor Prager | 16 | +4.00 (25.00%) | |
| D | Joan Capdevilla | 15 | +5.00 (33.33%) |  |
| D | David Unsworth | 13 | +5.00 (38.46%) | |
| D | Phil Jagielka | 12 | +4.00 (33.33%) | |
| M | Peter Beardsley | 15 | +5.00 (33.33%) | |
| M | Landon Donovan | 15 | +1.00 (6.67%) | |
| M | Bradley Billingham | 14 | +5.00 (35.71%) | |
| M | Peter Reid | 14 | +5.00 (35.71%) |  |
| M | Jack Rodwell | 14 | +4.00 (28.57%) | |
| S | Derek Dick | 14 | +4.00 (28.57%) | |
| 14.27 | +45.00 (28.66%) |
Possession / Performance
| Performance | Skill | Name | Pos | |
| +2.00 (14.29%) | 14 | Jorge Campos | K | |
| +2.00 (14.29%) | 14 | Bobby Moore | D | |
| +4.00 (30.77%) | 13 | Carlos Alberto Torres | D | |
| +2.00 (20.00%) | 10 | Gary Cahill | D | |
| -2.00 (-12.50%) | 16 | Jesús Navas | M | |
| +4.00 (26.67%) | 15 | Ashley Young | M | |
| +1.00 (7.69%) | 13 | David Beckham | M | |
|
0.00 (0.00%) | 12 | Jack Wilshere | M |
| +3.00 (30.00%) | 10 | Theo Walcott | M | |
| +4.00 (28.57%) | 14 | Luis Suarez | S | |
| +1.00 (7.69%) | 13 | Cristiano Ronaldo | S | |
| +1.00 (6.25%) | 16 | David Pizarro | R | |
| +22.00 (13.75%) | 13.33 |