| Pos | Name | Skill | Performance | |
| K | Peter Shilton | 9 | +2.10 (23.33%) | |
| D | Alf Ramsey | 12 | +2.90 (24.17%) | |
| D | Matt Busby | 12 | +1.70 (14.17%) | |
| D | Bill Shankly | 12 | +1.60 (13.33%) | |
| D | Phil Thompson | 9 | +3.40 (37.78%) |  |
| M | Bob Paisley | 11 | +2.30 (20.91%) | |
| M | Nigel Clough | 9 | +1.90 (21.11%) | |
| M | Alan Ball | 9 | +1.50 (16.67%) | |
| M | Graeme Souness | 9 | +1.40 (15.56%) | |
| S | Trevor Francis | 10 | +1.50 (15.00%) |  |
| S | Brian Clough | 10 | +1.20 (12.00%) | |
| 10.18 | +21.50 (19.20%) |
Possession / Performance
| Performance | Skill | Name | Pos | |
| -2.50 (-19.23%) | 13 | Ben Foster | K | |
| +2.10 (17.50%) | 12 | Rafael Pereira da Silva | D | |
| +1.10 (9.17%) | 12 | Jonathan Evans | D | |
| 0.00 (0.00%) | 10 | Monty Coppell | D | |
| +1.20 (15.00%) | 8 | Nathan Beeby | D | |
| +0.10 (0.83%) | 12 | Darron Gibson | M | |
| -2.40 (-20.00%) | 12 | Gabriel Obertan | M | |
| -1.40 (-12.73%) | 11 | Samson Hebden | M | |
| +0.10 (1.67%) | 6 | Harvey Dideah | M | |
| +0.40 (4.00%) | 10 | Federico Macheda | S | |
| -0.30 (-3.33%) | 9 | Nicolas Canizares | S | |
| -1.60 (-1.39%) | 10.45 |